The Mayhem began the defense of their 2017 SPHL Championship with an opening night roster that included thirteen returning players from the previous season. The biggest gap to fill would be in goal, as 2017 playoff MVP Jordan Ruby was offered the opportunity to play in Europe. Troy Passingham, Ruby’s backup for most of the previous season, was loaned to the ECHL at the start of the season, a trend that would continue throughout the 2017-18 campaign.
With the goaltending situation unsettled at the start, the team went 0-2-1 in their first three games of the season, all at home. After back to back wins on the road, the team returned home, only to drop another game in front of the home crowd. It wasn’t until November 10 that the Mayhem won their first home game, behind a 43 save performance by Troy Passingham.
The big story over the course of the season was a total of fourteen of the Mayhem’s top players were loaned to the following ECHL teams: Atlanta, Adirondack, Florida, Greenville, Indianapolis, Jacksonville, Orlando, Quad City, Rapid City, Toledo and Worcester. In total, Mayhem players suited up for over 175 ECHL games in 2017-18. While fans should be happy to see their players advance in their hockey careers, one does have to wonder what their impact might have been on the team if they had remained in Macon.
The saddest news came at the end of March when Mayhem Head Coach and Director of Hockey Operations Kevin Kerr announced that alternate captain Dennis Sicard has been placed on the injured reserve list for the remainder of the season. The fan favorite was in his 11th SPHL season and had amassed 112 goals, 120 assists, 232 points over 476 career games and currently is the SPHL all-time leader in penalty minutes with 2200.
The Mayhem finished the season in a tie for second place with Pensacola with both teams posting identical records of 33-16-7. The league used both team’s head-to-head season record as a tie breaker, which went to Macon. The top eight teams in the ten team league made the playoffs, and with the newly instituted Challenge Round, the top three teams were given the opportunity to select their first round opponent from the bottom four teams. #1 seed Peoria chose #8 Roanoke, while Macon chose #6 seed Evansville for their first round. The Mayhem dropped game one of the best of three opening round in Evansville by a 2-1 score, but then came home to soundly defeat the Thunderbolts in games two and three. The tables were turned in round two, with Macon picking up the first win in Huntsville but dropping the next two at home, including a heartbreaking overtime loss in the deciding game three.
Mayhem leading scorer Jake Trask and captain Daniel Gentzler both were honored by being named to the 2017-2018 All-SPHL First and Second teams respectively. Regular season attendance hit a three-season high of 2390 per game but still below the league average of 3214.
In May, Macon Mayhem Head Coach, General Manager and Director of Hockey Operations Kevin Kerr announced his resignation to accept the head coaching position with the ECHL Greenville Swamp Rabbits. The Mayhem quickly named assistant coach Leo Thomas as their new Head Coach and Director of Hockey Operations. Thomas becomes the first African-American head coach in the Southern Professional Hockey League. Thomas joins a trio of black head coaches in Macon’s hockey history behind John Paris Jr. and Graeme Townshend, who both coached the now defunct Macon Whoopee in the old Central Hockey League from 1996-97 to 2000-01.
The Mayhem started the 2018-19 season having signed goaltender Jordan Ruby and four of their five leading scorers from 2017-18 in Stathis Soumelidis, Caleb Cameron, John Siemer and leading scorer Jake Trask. After dropping their home opener against Pensacola, the Mayhem went on a nine game winning streak. The team started 2019 with a 17-5-3 record. From that point forward, the Mayhem were never able to string together more than two or three wins in a row.
ECHL call-ups helped exacerbate the problem. Goaltenders Gordon Defiel and Jordan Ruby were gone by early December. Defensemen Jake Faiella, Brandon Fehd, Zach Urban and forward Sam Wilbur all spent considerable time in the ECHL. While player call-ups are becoming the norm in the SPHL, it proves the league continues to develop quality talent, which enables players to advance their professional hockey careers.
Jarrett Rush, Michael Wills, Mark McGowan, Josh Ranalli and Connor Toomey watch the opening face-off from the bench during the Mayhem's first game in Macon. Photo courtesy of Philly Jones.
The Mayhem began the 2019-20 campaign with a 2-5-1-1 record, which included a six game winless streak beginning on November 1. On November 19, the team announced that it was parting ways with Head Coach Leo Thomas. Assistant Coach Ryan Michel was named Interim Head Coach and remained at the helm for the remainder of the season. The team improved slightly as the season progressed, had won seven of their last eleven games and still was in the hunt for a playoff spot when the SPHL announced on March 12 it was suspending play as a precautionary measure to prevent the spread of the coronavirus. Three days later, the league's Board of Governors voted unanimously to cancel of the remainder of the 2019-2020 regular season and playoffs.
The good news for Mayhem fans was the announcement on January 28, 2020, that Spectra Venue Management and team owners Bob and Diane Kerzner signed a five-year contract extension to keep the Mayhem at the Macon Coliseum. Among the bad news was attendance dropped to 1,867 per game, which was lowest among the ten teams in the SPHL, and the departure of Mark Kunkle as the original team mascot Mac the Barbarian.
The Mayhem finished the season in sixth place in the ten team league. Their 27-24-5 record earned them a spot in the SPHL Playoffs. Their first round opponent as determined by the league’s Challenge Round was the Knoxville Ice Bears. Macon had a 5-1-1 record when playing the Ice Bears during the regular season but the Mayhem dropped the first two games of the best of three series, earning them an early exit from the playoffs.
Some creative advertising displayed on the dasher at the visitor's bench made for some good photo opportunities, as evidenced by this March 16, 2019 photo taken of the Huntsville Havoc players by Erica Jaskula Moore.
In late June 2020, team owners Bob and Diane Kerzner announced they were selling the team to a new local ownership group consisting of Dr. John Sapp, Charles Olson, John Regan, Mason Bryan, and Blair Floyd. Less than a month later, General Manager Blair Floyd broke the news that Kevin Kerr would be returning to Macon as head coach and director of hockey operations.
At the end of July, the Southern Professional Hockey League (SPHL) announced it was planning to start the 2020-2021 regular season in mid-to-late December. Due to state and local health department restrictions, five of the ten SPHL teams were forced to sit out the abbreviated 2020-21 season.
The Mayhem dominated the SPHL with a 19-4-4 record as of April 1, 2021, clinching a playoff spot. By mid-April, the team had earned home ice advantage throughout the playoffs by capturing the William B. Coffey Trophy as Regular Season Champions. Macon finished the regular season with a 32-6-4 record. They defeated Huntsville in the first round and faced Pensacola in the finals. Despite going 10-0-2 against the Ice Flyers in the regular season, the Mayhem were swept in the best of three championship series, proving once again that anything can happen in a short playoff series.